Boat of Garten LXXIV

What a great weekend for our 74th (official) outing to Boat of Garten and very well done to Rob who will now be the 27th name to be engraved on the prestigious trophy. Both Boat of Garten and Spey Valley were looking great and the weather was lovely - well organised, Syd!

There will now actually be 76 engravings on the trophy as September, 1992 appears as "rained off" (the only time this has happened) and May, 2020 has a Covid asterisk against it.

Prior to the trophy being introduced in May, 1986 there were actually 3 outings which don't appear in the official records. The very first outing was in September, 1984 and was won by Dick.

Defending champion Syd remains well ahead at the top of the all-time leader board. Multiple winners of the trophy are:

There are solo wins from another 16 players - Bill Miller, Bob Cooper, Keith Murray, Peter Street, Mike Brogan, Bobby Fyfe, Dan Corbett, Keith Gray, Jas Bhagrath, Chris Dickinson, Ian Dring, Steve Fulford, Jack Simpson, Ken Black, Hugh Riches and now Rob Pollard.

Rob patiently waited for his first win but remember it took the maestro Syd 14 years before his first win. From those that took part back in the 1980's, Malcolm took 17 years before winning it, but the record goes to Jas, whose 2012 victory came after 27 years and over 50 attempts.

Anyway, back to this weekend. Here's the team at the start:

l-r: John Davies, Gordon Moir, Rob Pollard, John Meaden, Syd Freeman, Hugh Riches, Dick Taylor, an unusually camera-shy Harry Salter, Nigel Meany, Keith Gray, Ken Page and Ian Stewart

Boat of Garten was in great nick and was much more playable than it normally is in September when the heather and the gorse usually cause mayhem. This time the greenkeepers had been hard at work and had cleared a lot of the worst of it, so if you strayed off the fairways you could always find your ball and it was usually playable, which was reflected in the scoring. Rob scored a magnificent 41 points with the nearest challengers being me and Keith, both with 36. Rob was so good that he could even play left-handed:

Back to the Grant Arms in Grantown - some ale while watching the Boks destroy Scotland. Dinner was good as usual and then it was back to the conference room for some to watch the Wales - Fiji match.

Monday morning didn't look promising. We awoke to heavy skies, low cloud and rain. There had been altercations overnight with some of the residents experiencing the rain coming in to their rooms. The hotel were having some work done to the roof and the contractors had merely tarpaulined it over the weekend. Cue angry tourists.

It's a fairly short drive to Spey VALLEY golf course in Aviemore - 20-25 minutes south west - but there was a major faux pas from Gordon, who had never played there before. He keyed his destination in to his SatNav - Spey BAY golf club. After driving north for 20 minutes or so, he was a little alarmed to see that his SatNav said there was still another 50 minutes of driving in front of him. Urgent phone calls to various members of our group put him right and he quickly u-turned back south again - unfortunately not quick enough to make our start time.

Rob, Keith and I set off as a 3-ball in the last group and Gordon joined us on the 3rd tee having purloined another buggy from the starter. Our champion elect thought it was time for a photo to prove he had made it:

Tremendous views at Spey Valley. The greens were considerably slower than Boat of Garten's and, despite almost 2 decades of growth since it first opened, the fairways haven't completely knitted yet. The bunker sand was beautifully white although a bit deeper than ideal - that didn't stop Rob, who loved them and managed to get up and down each time he was in one.

After a slightly shaky front nine, when Keith briefly got within 2 shots of his overall total, Rob recovered on the back nine with a very tidy 19 points to give him a total of 31 and an unbeatable aggregate of 72. Rob became the second oldest winner of the trophy at the age of 74. Syd, of course, has already beaten that 3 times - at 75 in 2014, at 78 in 2021 and at 84 in May this year.

After soup and sannies in the clubhouse, Syd presented Rob with the trophy:

Here's all the aggregate scores:

The prizewinners were:

Interesting to note that the average points scored at Boat of Garten was 29.1, whereas it was just 24.8 at Spey Valley. Rob alluded to that back at the Boat Inn in Aboyne when he reminded us that next year - surprise, surprise - we'll all be a year older and he therefore thought it might be appropriate to revisit Grantown rather than Spey Valley. Watch this space.

Another big anniversary for the Boat of Garten outing is coming up in the next year or two - our 40th anniversary. Next September (2024), it'll be exactly 40 years since the first (pre-trophy) outing, although it'll only be our 39th official year. The proper 40th anniversary will be in 2025 - ten years after we had our 30:60 celebrations. Maybe 40:80 shirts then - if we're spared! 🤞

Terry Edmonds' Memorial XXII

Another glorious day at Aboyne yesterday - and well done to Ken Black who notched up his first win with a magnificent 42 points, equalling the record for this event, previously held by the late Les Gray (2006). Ken is now the 11th name on the trophy. The event has been played a total of 19 times now, with 2 further occasions when it was rained off and once Covid cancelled.

The all-time list of winners still shows Malcolm well ahead with 5 wins, followed by Paul, Les, myself and Keith with 2 each. Solo wins from the late Dave Edwards, Archie, Harry, Ken Page (who drove from his home in Spain to take part yesterday and at Boat of Garten), Gary and now Ken Black.

I've copied Gary's detailed match report below, but first, here's the photos from yesterday:

The starting 10 - l-r: me. Harry, Gary, Rob, Dick, Ken B, Ken P, Malcolm. Nigel and Syd

Regrettably, only 9 of the above managed to finish. After a good front nine, and despite Ken B supplying me with paracetomol on the 10th tee, playing 2 days in a row was too much for my knee and I had to walk in after 12 holes. I was, however, able to join Linda on the balcony and photograph each of the teams as they finished their rounds on the 18th:

Rob, Malcolm and Gary

Harry, Nigel and Dick

Syd, Ken P and Ken B

Here's the team photo, including Linda, before the meal:

Gary then did the prizegiving and Linda presented Ken B with the magnificent trophy:

Now Gary's match report:

"Well what a day - the sun obviously shines on the righteous! 

Thankfully some clouds passed over to cool the ambient temperature on the course.

Despite some early protestations and murmurings from certain quarters of team fixing, the end result vindicated my team selection. Average stableford score for the geeks was 32.88.

A new format was introduced in testing ones ability to hit a green in regulation - this was closest to the pin with a second shot at the 17th. However, a pin positioned close to the front of the green proved very difficult with only myself and Syd managing to succeed with the latter winning.

Rob hit the pin at the 8th having also done the same at the Eden course a few weeks ago. Perhaps we should have a special prize for this in the future.

There was great altercation about Ken B and Ken P's score. It appears everyone knew what was going on apart from moi.  Everyone was shouting at me and I am only small!!!

Overall winner was Ken Black ( not Page!) with 42 points; second place was Harry Salter with 36 despite hitting a wrong ball on the 2nd!

Team prize to Syd, Ken Page, Ken Black and Ian with total of 111. ( Ian Stewart retired early)."

Braemar 2023

Organiser Malcolm failed a late fitness test but still turned up at the start today to see the remaining 11 of us off. Braemar used to be a regular stop on BSV's outings but today was the first time we'd been back as a group for a few decades.

Ball in the bag start in 3-4-4 formation. Here's the first group driving off:

Then a team photo:

Who would wear these ankle bracelets - and why?:

The course was in good shape - the greens were sticky but true and, overall, scores were pretty healthy - only 2 were in the 20's. Ian D won the NP at the 5th (with the help of a fortuitous bounce) and Rob won the 18th. The longest drives at the 15th were won by Gary and Syd (70 +).

Syd won the individual stableford with 40 points, with Rob 2nd on 38 and Gary 3rd with 37. The clear team winners were Syd, Harry, Brian and Rob with an impressive average of 36.25, well ahead of the others. Their win was duly acknowledged but insufficient prize balls remained.

Good day out and it was generally agreed that this was a much better option than Blairgowrie. 

Balmoral 2023

It was our 22nd outing to Balmoral last night - and the first time we had managed, courtesy of our host Gary Coutts, to increase the number of Banchory guests to 12, signed on by 4 Balmoral members, each of whom played in one of the 4 fourballs.

Nigel volunteered to acquire the drinks for our post-golf celebrations:

We piled that lot, plus the food that Keith had prepared/acquired, in to the team bus along with 12 bodies and sets of clubs and set off to Balmoral, where Gary met us and took us in to the estate (back entrance this time).

We were threatened with an early shower but it came to nothing and soon we were back to blue skies again. Balmoral had lost their regular greenkeeper golfer, Duncan Stewart, who had been "poached" by the King and had moved to Dumfries House. The course this year wasn't in the best condition but the surroundings are lovely. The rough, however, was lethal, and there were many lost balls which kept the scoring lower than usual.

Jas hasn't been able to play golf this year but decided to give it a go last night. He had a somewhat embarrassing start when his opening drive rebounded behind the tee back almost to the clubhouse:

 As well as the above, Ian Sh sent me a few more photos he took last night:

Scorecard

Clubhouse

Either side of the 1st fairway, there are statues of Albert, Prince Consort and Queen Victoria looking over at each other

View from 2nd tee of Crathie Kirk

Of course, there had to be a team photo as well:

Gary Coutts standing between Ian D and Jas, with the 3 other Balmoral members - Brian, Peter and Brendan - on the far right

Now, the scores. 10 of our group of 16 had stableford points in the mid-20's - only 6 managed to reach the respectability threshold of 30 points and 3 of them were Balmoral members. I scored 31 points, Ian D had 33 and Harry 35.

The winner, for the 3rd time, was Balmoral member Brian Lees with 37 points. Harry took 2nd place. Nearest the pins were Gary and Brian whilst Ian D got the longest drive. The team prize went to Brendan, Harry, Hugh and Rob with a total of 107 points, taking the best scores 3 at each hole.

The Challenge 2022

There was a weather warning for strong winds in the morning but dry until the afternoon. They got it wrong - yes, there was a bit of wind but it certainly wasn't enough to merit a weather warning. The course, too, was looking very good for October - the greens were true and running well. Hugh had played in the medal yesterday when there were mud patches on the course so we decided to play preferred lies, but, in retrospect, there was no need - the fairways were fine.

Thankfully, no late cancellations so it was a full house of 20, playing in 5 fourball matches. The leading game was between the father and son team of Malcolm and Matthew Grigor against the formidable R.o.W. pairing of Ian Dring and Syd Freeman. Predictably, the "away" team had a reasonably comfortable 3 & 1 victory.

Match 2 went the same way, with Harry Salter and Raymond Orr (guesting for R.o.W.) defeating Brain Dawson and Ian Sharp 4 & 3. The 3rd match was much tighter, with Rob Pollard delighting his partner Nigel Meany by holing a tricky "9-footer" (according to Rob) on the final green to level the match with Dick Taylor and me.

Thankfully, matches 4 & 5 went Scotland's way - John Waddell and Keith Gray beat Hugh and Jackie Riches (also guesting for R.o.W.) 2 holes up, and Carol Dawson and Jack Simpson notching a 2 & 1 win over John Meaden and Julie Dring.

This was the 3rd overall tie in the 19 years since 2004 that this end of season event has been held. Scotland maintain the overall lead with 11 victories, with R.o.W. having 5.

We had 4 logo'd balls left so there were NP & LD competitions. Nigel got the NP at the 3rd hole and I got the one at the 7th. Ian Dring predictably won the LD at the 10th. The ladies' NP at the 3rd presented a bit of a problem as none of the 3 hit the green but, by popular acclaim, Jackie was awarded with the ball as she was the only one to clear the ditch.

Rob took the photo of me and Hugh with the trophy:

Barmaid Jacqui then took the team photo of those still present:

Unfortunately, no catering available this year but hopefully the meal will be back next year for our 20th event (if we're spared!)

Terry Edmonds' Memorial Trophy XXI 2022

Although the numbers dwindled over the last few weeks, there was a still a fairly healthy turnout for the event at Aboyne. For the first time we had a junior golfer joining us - 9 year old Eli, Paul and Samia's son, who played 9 holes with me, Paul and Malcolm. He looks like a future star and it won't be too long before he's beating his Dad - and the rest of us.

It was a fine afternoon and the course was in great nick. Best individual score on the day came from Gary, who had 37 points, just pipping Keith on countback. Here's the full list:

Harry and Gary got the NP's and Syd and Gary the two (age divided) LD's. As ever, the team competition, which was the best two at each hole, was a little controversial. I had indicated beforehand that there would be an appropriate reduction in the scores of the 4-man teams - probably 10%. Teams 2 & 3 scored 85 and 84 points respectively, while the 3-man team had 81 points, so any deduction of 5% or more would have been enough to seal victory for team 1. Gary challenged this and asked what would the result have been had we just used the overall team averages? Well, guess what - team 1 would still have won - their average was 32.7, whilst the other teams only averaged 31.3.

Linda, as usual, donated the prize balls and I had intended to give mine to young Eli, but I never even got my hands on it - Eli had already pocketed it!

Now the photos - first of all waiting for our post-match meal:

Keith took this photo just before he had to dash off and greet some unexpected visitors at home. After we'd eaten, we did the presentation out on the (west) balcony:

From l-r: Syd Freeman, Jack Simpson, Harry Salter (half hidden), Malcolm Grigor, Ian Stewart, Linda Edmonds, 16 year old Sam Edmonds (6'1" and still growing), Samia Saeed-Edmonds, Eli Edmonds, John Waddell, Gary Grant, Rob Pollard, Paul Edmonds and Nigel Meany.

Before handing over the trophy, there was a round of applause for Samia who had been awarded the MBE in the Queen's New Year Honours List for heading up NHS Wales' Covid team during the pandemic.

Here's Linda doing the honours with Gary:

The trophy was donated by Linda after Terry passed in December, 2001. The first planned playing for it in 2002 was rained off, as was the 2009 event. (Interestingly, none of our other events have been rained off twice - even our oldest outing to Boat of Garten, which has been played over 70 times now, has only been rained off once). Also, the event didn't take place in 2020 due to Covid, so there have only been 18 winners in the 21 years the competition has been held.

Gary and Malcolm are both members at Aboyne (as was Syd in the past). This was Gary's first win but Malcolm has won the trophy 5 times. Me, Paul Edmonds, the late Les Gray and Keith Gray (no relation) have each won it twice and there have been solo wins for the late Dave Edwards, Archie Cook, Harry Salter and Ken Page.

I don't have a record of Keith's winning score in 2017, but, from the other years, Les has the highest winning points with 42 in 2006.

We look forward to next year's event and hopefully Paul, Samia and the boys can make the long trip north again.

The Challenge XVIII

The doom-laden weather forecasts from earlier in the week were a thankfully distant memory as, appropriately, 18 of us lined up on a coolish but fair morning for the 18th consecutive playing of this now traditional season closing event. The earlier starters lined up for a team photo on the first tee:

The top match was between Malcolm and Raymond, representing Scotland, and this year's Quaich winner Harry, partnered by Syd, with Scotland coming out on top by the surprisingly high margin of 5 & 4. The next two matches had to be 3-balls so I had to devise a system of matchplay that would be fair to both teams - and each of the participants. Two Scots - Keith and me - played Rob, whilst Dick faced Nigel and John W, who was hastily transferred (under duress) to the R.o.W. team at the last minute. Individual stableford scores were the basis, with the 2-man team aggregates divided by two. Both Keith and I struggled to play the same holes well and, standing on the 15th tee, Rob was 3 holes up and hoping to be able to walk in victorious at the Doo'cot. It wasn't to be, with Keith and I winning the last 4 holes to narrowly take the match for Scotland by just one hole. Subsequently, Keith queried whether we could have "done a Nicklaus" and conceded Rob's tricky downhill 6 foot putt so that the match was tied - but too late. After all, this was at stake:

Nigel and John W didn't have as much trouble in their match, comfortably beating Dick by 4 & 3. The last 2 matches were mixed - and married - fourballs. The Sharps beat the McWhinnies 2 up - not that John and Joan, having to represent R.o.W., were too disappointed. The final match between the Moirs (for Scotland) and the Riches (R.o.W.) was interesting as, normally, both Lynda and Jackie would have been playing for the opposite side from their husbands, but, in the interests of marital bliss, on this occasion they had to go over to the dark side. It was reported that Lynda played fantastically well, with two net eagles and a few birdies, so Scotland won this match 5 & 3, so taking the overall score to 4 matches to 1 in Scotland's favour. After lunch, most of the winning team (minus Raymond) lined up on the steps outside for the team photo:

The overall result since 2004 now reads Scotland 12, R.o.W. 6.